Ohio Eats · checked by hand, fall 2026
Ohio pizza styles
15 pizzerias for the pizza Ohio made its own: Columbus's thin crust, Dayton's thin, square-cut pies, Ohio Valley squares and Youngstown's Brier Hill style, each checked in fall 2026 against a 2025–26 source.
Cut in squares
Most Ohio pizzerias cut a round pie into small squares, and several cities have a style of their own. Columbus-style is a thin, crisp crust with the toppings spread right to the edge. Dayton-style, from Marion's Piazza (1965), is thin and square-cut too. Ohio Valley-style, from Steubenville and the river towns, is baked in a rectangular pan and topped with cold cheese and toppings after it leaves the oven. Youngstown's Brier Hill pizza is a thicker crust under red sauce, bell peppers and Romano.
The list at a glance
Towns with the most: Dayton (6), Columbus (2), Youngstown (2), Toronto (1), Mason (1), Englewood (1), Troy (1), Warren (1).
Our method: a place made the list only if a page names it for this food (a local news story, Ohio Magazine, a tourism board or the place's own site) and something from 2025 or 2026 shows it's open: a dated page, the place's own site with its current hours when we looked, or a 2025–26 Cincinnati inspection. Its street address had to match our records. Review sites played no part, and places run by region and town rather than by anybody's score. Hours change, so check before you go.
On your phone, Ohio Eats orders this list by how far each place is from you, and a tap opens Apple Maps' live card with hours, photos and directions.
Other guides: Cincinnati chili, Amish Country, James Beard honors, Cincinnati & Columbus inspections. City pages: Cincinnati, Columbus, Cleveland, Dayton.
Jump to a region
Cincinnati & Southwest
1 pizzeria, by town.
Marion's Piazza
6176 Sound Wave Dr, Mason
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Dayton & Miami Valley
8 pizzerias, by town.
Marion's Piazza
8991 Kingsridge Dr, Dayton
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Marion's Piazza
3443 N Dixie Dr, Dayton
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Marion's Piazza
711 Shroyer Rd, Dayton
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Marion's Piazza
1320 N Fairfield Rd, Dayton
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Marion's Piazza
50 E Stroop Rd, Dayton
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Marion's Piazza
241 N Main St, Dayton
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Marion's Piazza
404 W National Rd, Englewood
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Marion's Piazza
1270 Experiment Farm Rd, Troy
Ohio pizza style
Thin-crust, square-cut “Dayton-style” pizza (its own menu), established 1965.
Columbus & Central
2 pizzerias, by town.
Rubino's Pizza
2643 E Main St, Columbus
Ohio pizza style
Columbus-style thin crust in Bexley since 1954 (its own site); cash only.
Terita's Pizza
3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus
Ohio pizza style
North End Columbus-style pizza for over 60 years (its own site).
Akron, Canton & Youngstown
4 pizzerias, by town.
Iggy's Pizza
1332 Franklin St, Toronto
Ohio pizza style
Ohio Valley-style square slices (its own site).
Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza
8250 High St NE, Warren
Ohio pizza style
Youngstown-area pizzeria Ohio Magazine names for Brier Hill-style pizza.
Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza
1622 S Raccoon Rd, Youngstown
Ohio pizza style
Youngstown-area pizzeria Ohio Magazine names for Brier Hill-style pizza.
Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza
6200 South Ave, Youngstown
Ohio pizza style
Youngstown-area pizzeria Ohio Magazine names for Brier Hill-style pizza.