Pennsylvania Eats guide · checked October 2026
Tomato pie & Old Forge pizza
36 bakeries and pizzerias for Philadelphia tomato pie or Old Forge-style trays, each checked in business in October 2026 against a dated 2025 or 2026 source.
Free on iPhone and iPad. Not in the App Store yet.
Two square pies, two ends of the state
Philadelphia tomato pie is a thick, square-cut focaccia-like crust under a sweet tomato sauce with a little grated cheese and no mozzarella, usually sold by the slice or the half-sheet at room temperature. Old Forge pizza, from the borough of Old Forge near Scranton, is baked in rectangular trays and sold by the tray or the cut: red with sauce and cheese, or white, a double crust with onions and herbs.
The 36 on this list
19 tomato pie bakeries and pizzerias and 17 Old Forge-style pizzerias, some of them more than one. They're in 3 regions of the state. 4 other places in the app's directory have “tomato pie” or “Old Forge” in their name; they're in the directory and the web search, but not on this list until we check them.
How the list was built: In October 2026 we looked up every place here in a 2025 or 2026 source (the shop's own site or menu, a dated post, local reporting, or a tourism listing) and matched its address. No current source, no listing. Review sites played no part, and the order is by region and city, not by anyone's rating. Menus and hours move, so call first.
Each place shows its official record where one is published in bulk, whether a Philadelphia place holds an active City food license, and elsewhere a link to the agency's own inspection search. In the app, this list puts the nearest places first, with Apple Maps' live card a tap away for hours and photos.
Jump to a region
The list is grouped by 9 regions of the state, Philadelphia first.
- Philadelphia (16)
- Philly Suburbs (3)
- Northeast & Poconos (17)
City pages: Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Allentown, Lancaster, Erie, Harrisburg, Reading, Scranton, State College, York, Bethlehem, Wilkes-Barre, West Chester, Altoona, Williamsport, Johnstown, Easton.
Philadelphia
16 places, by city or town. See the Philadelphia page for the region.
Cacia's Bakery
1526 W Ritner St, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Dead King Bread
5100 Umbria St, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
No City food license matchedCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Downtime Bakery
6614-24 Germantown Ave, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Fiore
2413 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Gaeta's Tomato Pies
7616 Castor Ave, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
No City food license matchedCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Iannelli's Bakery
1155 E Passyunk Ave, Philadelphia
Tomato pieSeasonal Known for: tomato pie · Season: Open to the public 15 to 20 days a year, mostly weekends from October to December
South Philadelphia bakery whose brick oven dates to about 1910; it ships pies and opens to the public only on some days.
No City food license matchedCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Joseph's Pizza Parlor
7947 Oxford Ave, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
No City food license matchedCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Liberty Kitchen Phl
1400 N Front St, Philadelphia
Roast porkHoagiesTomato pie Known for: roast pork, Italian hoagie, tomato pie
Fishtown sandwich shop and grocery on Visit Philly's roast pork and hoagie guides.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Machine Shop
1901 S 9th St, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Marchiano's Bakery
4653 Umbria St, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
New York Bakery
2215 S 11th St, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Paffuto
1009 S 8th St, Philadelphia
CheesesteaksTomato pie Known for: cheesesteak, tomato pie
Steak shop on the Inquirer's April 2025 list of the area's best cheesesteaks.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Pietramala
614 N 2nd St, Philadelphia
MICHELIN Green StarTomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
MICHELIN Guide, Philadelphia, 2025 selection: MICHELIN Green Star
No City food license matchedCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Pizzeria Beddia
1313 N Lee St, Philadelphia
Bib GourmandTomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
MICHELIN Guide, Philadelphia, 2025 selection: Bib Gourmand
No City food license matchedCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Santucci's Original Square Pizza
901 S 10th St, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Active City food licenseCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Sarcone's Bakery
758 S 9th St, Philadelphia
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
No City food license matchedCity of Philadelphia L&I; inspection reports are search-only
Philly Suburbs
3 places, by city or town, most in Ardmore, Berwyn, and Norristown. See the Philly Suburbs page for the region.
Carlino's Specialty Foods
2616 E County Line Rd, Ardmore
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Settantatre Pasta & Provisions
802 Lancaster Ave, Berwyn
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Corropolese Italian Bakery and Deli
2014 Old Arch Rd, Norristown
Tomato pie Known for: tomato pie
On the Inquirer's September 2025 guide to the region's tomato pies.
Montgomery County posts inspection reports one search at a time.
Northeast & Poconos
17 places, by city or town, most in Old Forge, Pittston, and Avoca. See the Northeast & Poconos page for the region.
Colarusso's Cafe
725 Main St, Avoca
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Mainline Hoagie & Pizza
Dickson City
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Cali's Don Tomaso Peatza
529 E Drinker St, Dunmore
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Colarusso's 2.0
941 Main St, Duryea
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Biscotto's
163 Susquehanna Ave, Exeter
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Anthony's Restaurant
202 S Main St, Old Forge
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Arcaro and Genell
443 S Main St, Old Forge
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Augustine's Club 17
518 N Main St, Old Forge
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Bobo's Pizza
201 N Main St, Old Forge
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Cusumano
432 S Main St, Old Forge
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Revello's Pizza
502 S Main St, Old Forge
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Salerno's Cafe
139 Moosic Rd, Old Forge
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Arcaro's The Next Generation
Pittston
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
De Muro's Pizza
10 William St, Pittston
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Alfredo's Pizza
1040 S Washington Ave, Scranton
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
The Dough Company
570 Kidder St, Wilkes-Barre
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
Togoz Pizza
310 Wyoming Ave, Wyoming
Old Forge pizza Known for: Old Forge-style white tray
Northeastern Pennsylvania pizzeria serving Old Forge-style double-crust white trays, on a September 2026 NEPA roundup.
Inspections: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search, one search at a time.
About inspections
In Philadelphia, “licensed” means an active City of Philadelphia L&I food license was matched to the place (OpenDataPhilly, City of Philadelphia License; licenses issued through Oct 11, 2026). It says the place is licensed, not how an inspection went. The Department of Public Health posts inspection reports one search at a time, with no grade or score: Philadelphia inspection reports. In the City's words:
“The City of Philadelphia makes no representation about the accuracy of any specific information in this data and is provided “as is” and without Warranty of any kind.”
Bucks and Montgomery counties inspect their own restaurants and post reports one search at a time, so we link to them: Bucks County, Montgomery County.
Everywhere else, the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture and about 100 local health departments post inspection results in one search, place by place: the PA Food Safety Inspection Search. We link to it and don't copy it, and there is no statewide grade. In the Department's words:
“Please remember that any inspection is a 'snapshot' of the day and time of the inspection. An inspection conducted on any given day may not be representative of the overall, long-term cleanliness of an establishment. Also, at the time of the inspection, violations are recorded but are often corrected on site prior to the inspector leaving the establishment.”