Indiana Eats · checked by hand, fall 2026
Amish country
5 restaurants in Elkhart and LaGrange counties, each on its county visitors bureau's own page, checked in fall 2026.
Middlebury and Shipshewana
The Elkhart County visitors bureau lists Das Dutchman Essenhaus, a family-style Amish restaurant, the Village Inn on Middlebury's Main Street and the Blue Gate in Shipshewana; Visit Shipshewana adds the Auction Restaurant, with chicken and noodles and homemade pies, and the Country Corral. The bureaus also list in-home Amish dinners by reservation; those aren't walk-in restaurants, so they aren't here.
The list at a glance
Towns with the most: Shipshewana (3), Middlebury (2).
Our method: a place made the list only if a 2025 or 2026 source backed it up (a dated story, or an Indiana tourism office's own page for it) and its street address matched. No current source, or a website gone dark, and it stayed off. Review sites played no part, and places run by region and town rather than by anybody's score.
On your phone, Indiana Eats orders this list by how far each place is from you, and a tap opens Apple Maps' live card with hours, photos and directions.
Other guides: Breaded tenderloins, Drive-ins & root beer, Hoosier pie, James Beard honors, Checking an inspection, Oldest restaurants. City pages: Indianapolis.
Jump to a region
- Elkhart County (2)
- LaGrange County (3)
Elkhart County
2 restaurants, by town.
Das Dutchman Essenhaus
240 US Highway 20, Middlebury
Hoosier pieAmish country
A family-style Amish restaurant, the Elkhart County visitors bureau's first pick.
Village Inn Restaurant
107 S Main St, Middlebury
Amish country
A small-town café on Main Street in Middlebury.
LaGrange County
3 restaurants, by town.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
195 N Van Buren St, Shipshewana
Amish country
Amish home-style meals and a bakery in Shipshewana.
Country Corral Restaurant
260 E North Village Dr, Shipshewana
Amish country
Comfort food in Shipshewana: meatloaf and pot roast.
Shipshewana Auction Restaurant
345 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana
Amish country
A sit-down restaurant at the auction: chicken and noodles and homemade pies.