Indiana Eats · checked by hand, fall 2026
Hoosier pie
6 dining rooms on Visit Indiana's Best Pies list, from sugar cream pie in a state park inn to Amish-country berry pie. Checked in fall 2026.
Sugar cream and the rest
Visit Indiana's Best Pies list names sugar cream pie at Clifty Inn in Clifty Falls State Park, peanut butter pie at the Olde Richmond Inn, pecan pie at the Fort Harrison State Park Inn, berry pie at Das Dutchman Essenhaus, cobblers at the Stone Hearth Café and mini peanut butter pies at the Abe Martin Lodge in Brown County State Park. Wick's Pie's own shop in Winchester, also on the list, is a bakery rather than a dining room.
The list at a glance
Towns with the most: Nashville (1), Madison (1), Middlebury (1), Indianapolis (1), Richmond (1), Centerville (1).
Our method: a place made the list only if a 2025 or 2026 source backed it up (a dated story, or an Indiana tourism office's own page for it) and its street address matched. No current source, or a website gone dark, and it stayed off. Review sites played no part, and places run by region and town rather than by anybody's score.
On your phone, Indiana Eats orders this list by how far each place is from you, and a tap opens Apple Maps' live card with hours, photos and directions.
Other guides: Breaded tenderloins, Drive-ins & root beer, Amish country, James Beard honors, Checking an inspection, Oldest restaurants. City pages: Indianapolis.
Jump to a region
- Brown County (1)
- Elkhart County (1)
- Jefferson County (1)
- Marion County (1)
- Wayne County (2)
Brown County
1 dining room, by town.
Abe Martin Lodge
1405 State Road 46 W, Nashville
Hoosier pie
Mini peanut butter pies at the lodge in Brown County State Park.
Elkhart County
1 dining room, by town.
Das Dutchman Essenhaus
240 US Highway 20, Middlebury
Hoosier pieAmish country
A family-style Amish restaurant, the Elkhart County visitors bureau's first pick.
Jefferson County
1 dining room, by town.
Clifty Inn
1650 Clifty Hollow Rd, Madison
Hoosier pie
Sugar cream pie, Indiana's state pie, in the inn at Clifty Falls State Park.
Marion County
1 dining room, by town.
Fort Harrison State Park Inn
5830 N Post Rd, Indianapolis
Hoosier pie
Pecan pie at the inn in Fort Harrison State Park.
Wayne County
2 dining rooms, by town.
Stone Hearth Cafe
2131 N Centerville Rd, Centerville
Hoosier pie
Cobblers and pies by the hearth.
Old Richmond Inn
138 S 5th St, Richmond
Hoosier pie
Peanut butter pie in a historic downtown dining room.