Garden State Eats · checked by hand, fall 2026

Subs and sloppy joes

8 delis and sub shops, each confirmed in fall 2026 against a 2025 or 2026 source: long Italian subs at the Shore and, in Essex and Union counties, the sloppy joe.

Ask for early accessThe free Garden State Eats app for iPhone and iPad is on its way to the App Store.

Jersey's own sloppy joe

In North Jersey a sloppy joe isn't loose meat on a bun. It's sliced deli meat and Swiss cheese with coleslaw and Russian dressing, layered on thin rye and cut into squares for a party platter. At the Shore, subs come long, on bread baked that day.

The list at a glance

In 8 towns: Atlantic City, Cherry Hill, Cranford, Middletown, Millburn, Point Pleasant Beach, Red Bank and South Orange Village.

Our method: a place made the list only if a dated 2025 or 2026 source named it (local news, a food site or the place's own site), or an older one did and Monmouth's or Camden's county health department inspected it in 2025 or 2026, and its street address matched our records. Review sites played no part, and places run by region and town rather than by anybody's score. Hours change, so check before you go.

On your phone, Garden State Eats orders this list by how far each place is from you, and a tap opens Apple Maps' live card with hours, photos and directions.

Other guides: Diners, Pork roll, egg & cheese, Tomato pie, Hot dogs, BYOB, Shore seafood, James Beard honors, New Jersey restaurant inspections.

Jump to a region

North Jersey

3 places, by town.

  1. Mr. J's Deli

    15 Walnut Ave, Cranford

    Subs

    Its own take on the sloppy joe.

  2. Millburn Deli

    328 Millburn Ave, Millburn

    Subs

    Known for the Jersey sloppy joe on rye.

  3. Town Hall Deli

    74 1st St, South Orange Village

    Pork rollSubs

    Pork roll, egg and cheese, and the sloppy joe on double-decker rye.

Jersey Shore

4 places, by town.

  1. White House Subs

    2301 Arctic Ave, Atlantic City

    America's ClassicSubs

    Italian subs on bread delivered fresh through the day.

  2. Taliercio's

    544 Road 35, Middletown

    Subs

    Oversized subs and sandwiches.

  3. Joe Leone's Italian Specialties

    510 Nj-35, Point Pleasant Beach

    Subs

    Italian subs at the Shore.

  4. Elsie's Sub Shop

    74 Monmouth St, Red Bank

    Subs

    A Red Bank sub shop.

    Latest placard: Satisfactory, Monmouth County Office of Public Health, July 23, 2026.

South Jersey

1 place, by town.

  1. Chick's Deli

    906 Township Ln, Cherry Hill

    Subs

    Cheesesteaks and hoagies.

    Latest placard: Satisfactory, Camden County Department of Health, September 23, 2024.