Garden State Eats · checked by hand, fall 2026

Trenton tomato pie

7 places for tomato pie, each confirmed in fall 2026 against a 2025 or 2026 source. Trenton's style lays the mozzarella on a thin crust first and spreads the crushed tomatoes over it.

Ask for early accessThe free Garden State Eats app for iPhone and iPad is on its way to the App Store.

Cheese first, tomatoes on top

Trenton's Chambersburg neighborhood made the tomato pie famous, and Papa's, which opened there in 1912, and De Lorenzo's now both bake in Robbinsville. The crust is thin and crisp, and the tomatoes go on last.

The list at a glance

Towns with the most: Robbinsville (2), Jersey City (1), Chesterfield (1), Hainesport (1), Gloucester City (1), Bordentown Township (1).

Our method: a place made the list only if a dated 2025 or 2026 source named it (local news, a food site or the place's own site), or an older one did and Monmouth's or Camden's county health department inspected it in 2025 or 2026, and its street address matched our records. Review sites played no part, and places run by region and town rather than by anybody's score. Hours change, so check before you go.

On your phone, Garden State Eats orders this list by how far each place is from you, and a tap opens Apple Maps' live card with hours, photos and directions.

Other guides: Diners, Pork roll, egg & cheese, Hot dogs, Subs & sloppy joes, BYOB, Shore seafood, James Beard honors, New Jersey restaurant inspections.

Jump to a region

North Jersey

1 place, by town.

  1. Razza

    275 Grove St, Jersey City

    James Beard finalistTomato pie

    Wood-fired pies; Dan Richer was a 2025 James Beard finalist.

Central Jersey

2 places, by town.

  1. De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies

    2350 Nj-33, Robbinsville

    Tomato pie

    The Trenton tomato pie family; the original Hudson Street shop closed in 2012.

  2. Papa's Tomato Pies

    19 Main St, Robbinsville

    Tomato pie

    Trenton tomato pie, cheese down first with crushed tomatoes on top; also a mustard pie.

South Jersey

4 places, by town.

  1. Palermo's

    674 US-206, Bordentown Township

    Tomato pie

    A Route 206 pizzeria that NJ 101.5 named for Trenton-style tomato pie.

  2. Gervasio's Italian Family Restaurant

    95 Saddle Way, Crosswicks (Chesterfield)

    Tomato pie

    An Italian family restaurant that NJ 101.5 named for tomato pie.

  3. Lillo's Tomato Pies

    157 S Burlington St, Gloucester City

    Tomato pie

    Its Original Tomato Pie is a homage to Trenton's, on South Burlington Street.

  4. Lillo's Tomato Pies

    2503 Marne Hwy, Hainesport

    Tomato pie

    Its Original Tomato Pie is a homage to Trenton's, on Marne Highway.